(http://washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A6213-2000Oct24?language=printer).
The Pentagon is hiring 450 counterintelligence specialists to protect
defense secrets after learning that China has obtained classified U.S.
missile technology, including critical information about the heat shield
that keeps America's most advanced missiles from burning up as they
reenter the atmosphere, senior defense officials said.
While applauding the attempt to boost security, members of Congress said
it was long overdue, coming more than five years after the Defense
Department was told of the suspected Chinese espionage.
A trove of Chinese military documents, given to the CIA in 1995 by a
former Chinese missile specialist, showed that Beijing had gathered some
classified data about U.S. nuclear weapons and a great deal of secret
information about America's ballistic missiles, according to officials
familiar with the material.
The Energy Department reacted quickly to the apparent loss of nuclear
secrets, launching a probe that focused on Los Alamos National
Laboratory and scientist Wen Ho Lee. But the Defense Department has been
slower to respond to what officials now say was the far more substantial
evidence that China had obtained significant missile technology.
Over the past two years, Congress has pressed the Energy Department to
take drastic measures to tighten security at the national laboratories,
such as requiring polygraph or "lie detector" exams for thousands of
employees. But little congressional pressure has been applied to the
Pentagon, which now is moving to tighten its control over missile
technology at military installations and private defense contractors.
Pentagon spokesman Kenneth Bacon said this week in response to inquiries
from The Washington Post that it will take until 2002 to bring on board
all 450 counterintelligence specialists, roughly the same number
eliminated since the end of the Cold War for budgetary reasons.
"All the new specialists will work to protect technical secrets at the
Defense Department laboratories and defense contractors," Bacon said,
adding that "other procedural techniques and monitoring tools" will be
used to improve security.
The counterintelligence officers are being hired through the Pentagon's
civil service procedures and are expected to come primarily from the
military, local police forces and the ranks of former government
employees, according to a Pentagon official. Some will work in
Washington and others at defense facilities around the country.
Sen. Richard C. Shelby (R-Ala.), chairman of the Senate Select Committee
on Intelligence, said in an interview that his committee staff has been
urging the Pentagon to add counterintelligence positions since 1997.
Shelby called the Pentagon's failure to investigate the loss of missile
technology "a big concern." China's apparent theft of missile secrets
from the Defense Department or its contractors is at least as troubling
as the Energy Department's alleged loss of secrets related to nuclear
warheads, he said.
Rep. Porter J. Goss (R-Fla.), chairman of the House Permanent Select
Committee on Intelligence, said the slow response reflects broader
security problems at the Pentagon, including a backlog of about 1
million people awaiting routine re-investigations of their security clearances.
"It is such a huge problem," Goss said. "They are whittling away at the
pile there."
Most of the approximately 60 espionage cases in the Defense Department
over the past 20 years have involved people who had been cleared to
handle classified documents. Top-secret clearances are required to be
re-investigated every five years, secret clearances every 10 years and
confidential clearances every 15 years.
Rep. Christopher Cox (R-Calif.), chairman of a House select committee
that investigated Chinese espionage at the national laboratories, said
he believes the CIA and the entire U.S. intelligence community share
responsibility for the Defense Department's failure to conduct a prompt
investigation of the loss of missile technology.
"The problem could have been alleviated if any member of the
intelligence community had shown special initiative," Cox said.
In 1995, according to senior intelligence officials, a Chinese missile
specialist approached the CIA with an unsolicited offer to provide
secret Chinese military documents. Over a period of months, this
"walk-in" agent handed over about 13,000 pages, The Post reported last week.
One of the first sections to be translated contained physical data about
the W-88, a nuclear warhead on U.S. submarine-launched missiles. This
triggered a 1996 probe by the Energy Department and the FBI, which the
Justice Department later concluded had focused too narrowly on Lee.
The government never charged him with espionage, and he was freed last
month after nine months in jail when he pleaded guilty to a single
felony count of downloading classified data to computer tapes.
While the Energy Department and the FBI may have moved precipitously, at
least in singling out Lee, the Defense Department hardly reacted at all.
Government officials have suggested two reasons: The intelligence
community was slow to translate all 13,000 pages from Mandarin to
English, completing that work only last year, and the CIA suspected on
the basis of a failed polygraph exam that the walk-in defector was a
Chinese double agent.
But after the FBI brought the defector to the United States for further
questioning, it concluded that he was legitimate, and senior
intelligence officials said the information he provided has proved
accurate.
Cox said this week that the CIA assured his committee in late 1998 that
the untranslated portions were "mundane." Senior intelligence officials
conceded that there were delays in translating the documents, but they
said the Pentagon, the FBI and the Energy Department were informed in
1995 that China apparently had obtained classified information about the
Trident II reentry vehicle on U.S. nuclear missile submarines.
"The Pentagon knew that in 1995, the FBI knew that in '95, DOE knew it,"
the official said.
The intelligence officials also said that since the fall of 1996, the
CIA's Counterintelligence Center sent about five separate "crimes
reports" to the FBI as the gradual translation of the documents yielded
evidence that missile and warhead secrets had been compromised by the
U.S. military or its contractors.
One former senior Pentagon official who was briefed on the walk-in
documents in 1997 said the Trident II information obtained by China was
"extremely accurate." It included a description of the sophisticated
mating, or attachment mechanism, of the nuclear warhead inside the
Mark-5 reentry vehicle, as well as of the materials that make up the
heat shield.
Whether China was able to improve its own missiles because of the U.S.
data remains unclear. "China's technical advances have been made on the
basis of classified and unclassified information derived from espionage,
contact with U.S. and other countries' scientists, conferences and
publications, unauthorized media disclosures, declassified U.S. weapons
information, and Chinese indigenous development," a CIA damage
assessment said last year.
"The relative contribution of each cannot be determined," it concluded.
But whatever its practical value, such information "should not be in
Chinese hands" and most likely got there through espionage, a U.S.
intelligence official said.