5 February 2003
MOD RESPONDS TO U.S. REQUEST TO UPGRADE RAF FYLINGDALES
Press Notice no: 025/03


http://news.mod.uk/news/press/news_press_notice.asp?newsItem_id=2271

The Secretary of State for Defence, Geoff Hoon, today responded to the United States' request to upgrade RAF Fylingdales.

In a written statement to the House of Commons, Mr Hoon said:

"On 17 December I informed the House of the receipt of a request from the United States Government to upgrade the early warning radar at Fylingdales for missile defence purposes.

"The Government has encouraged Parliamentary and public discussion of the issues involved.  On 17 October, I informed the House of current work in the US on missile defence and, on 9 December, published a discussion paper, inviting interested parties to contribute their views.  We have received a large number of responses both from individuals and organisations, and we have considered all contributions carefully.  I have visited North Yorkshire to explain what the upgrade would involve and to hear at first hand the views of local people.  We have engaged in initial discussions with the planning authorities.  In an oral Statement on 15 January, I informed the House of the Government's preliminary conclusion that it was in the UK's interest to agree to the US request.  I gave evidence to the Defence Select Committee on the same day and addressed points raised by hon Members in the Defence Debate on 22 January.  I welcome the Select Committee's conclusion, in their report published on 29 January, that the UK should agree to the upgrade.

"In the course of these discussions we have been able to clarify that: the upgrade essentially comprises computer hardware and software modification, and involves no new development or change to the external appearance or power output of the radar; the radar will continue to fulfil its long-established Ballistic Missile Early Warning System (BMEWS) role; it will continue to be operated and staffed by the Royal Air Force, and we will continue to enjoy full access to its data; and the upgrade does not of itself commit the UK Government to any greater participation in the US missile defence programme.  It does, however, keep open the prospect of acquiring missile defence capabilities for the UK, should we desire such protection at some point in the future.  We will continue discussions with the local planning authorities on the detail of the upgrade work.

"I am now satisfied that we have been able to take fully into account the views of all interested parties in coming to a decision.  I am therefore today replying to the United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld, conveying the Government's agreement to the US request.  We are separately negotiating a technical Memorandum of Understanding to give British industry the best possible opportunities to win work on the US programme."

 


5 February 2003
UK to help 'Son of Star Wars'
By Matt Kelley
BBC News


http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/2729029.stm


Fylingdales
  Some fear the Fylingdales scheme could harm the UK

The UK has formally agreed to an American request to use a Yorkshire air force base for its controversial "Son of Star Wars" missile defence shield.

Defence Secretary Geoff Hoon announced the decision about RAF Fylingdales in a written statement in Parliament.

Mr Hoon had already told MPs the UK was "minded" to agree to the American scheme, which is opposed by several Labour MPs.

On Friday, he said he was "satisfied that we have been able to take fully into account the views of all interested parties in coming to a decision".

Geoff Hoon, Defence Secretary
Hoon: Satisfied all views heard

Mr Hoon continued: "I am therefore today replying to the United States Secretary of Defence Donald Rumsfeld, conveying the government's agreement to the US request."

The news is set to anger opponents of the plan, who have already complained there has only been scant consultation about the US request.

The Commons defence select committee has also pointed to a lack of proper consultation with residents near the North York Moors base.

Upgrade details

In his statement, Mr Hoon said the upgrade would not change the external appearance or power output" of the base.

There would also be no new development, but computer software and hardware would change.

Mr Hoon added: "The radar will continue to fulfil its long-established ballistic missile early warning system role, it will continue to be operated and staffed by the Royal Air Force and we will continue to enjoy full access to its data.

"The upgrade does not of itself commit the UK Government to any greater participation in the US missile defence programme.

"It does, however, keep open the prospect of acquiring missile defence capabilities for the UK, should we desire such protection at some point in the future.

"We will continue discussions with the local planning authorities on the detail of the upgrade work."

The Conservatives favour the scheme, but said it was typical the government had "smuggled out an unpopular announcement".

Shadow defence secretary Bernard Jenkin said: "They stifled debate on missile defence until the Christmas holidays, and then rushed out the policy through with the minimum of debate.

"The whole process stinks of hypocrisy."

The Liberal Democrats have already accused ministers of undermining their own consultation process by moving too quickly.

Last month, Mr Hoon told MPs a threat of a ballistic missile attack by rogue states could materialise.

He said the missile system could represent "an invaluable extra insurance against the development of a still uncertain but potentially catastrophic threat to the citizens of this country".

Independence threat?

Opponents say the scheme is unnecessary, would not work and would simply make the UK a target - without giving it a protective screen of missiles.

Former Labour Defence Minister Peter Kilfoyle has attacked what he termed Mr Hoon's "slavish devotion to American policy in this area".

In the last debate, Mr Kilfoyle spoke of "the government's gathering rush to embrace every crackpot notion foisted upon us by the ideologues in Washington".

Fellow Labour MP Alice Mahon told Mr Hoon that government policy was out of kilter with the opinion of the vast majority of people who elected Labour.

'Expensive and dubious'

Fylingdales has an advanced radar which could track missiles launched by rogue states or terrorists in, for example, the Middle East.

They would then in theory be shot down as they neared the US coast.

Labour MP Malcolm Savidge has described the system as an "extremely expensive and technically dubious defence against a very improbable form of attack".

In December, the government published a report arguing that taking part in the US plans would not immediately put the UK itself at greater risk of attack.

And in November the US head of the missile defence Lieutenant General Ronald Kadish, visited the site on a "familiarisation" trip.


5 February 2003
GREEN LIGHT IS GIVEN FOR FYLINGDALES
BBC CEEFAX

Confirmation that America can use the Fylingdales early warning base on the North York Moors for its missile defence system has been given, Defence Secretary Geoff Hoon told MP's of the decision on Wednesday.

He said he was satisfied the views of all interested parties had been taken into account.

But opponents have argued it will make Britain more of a target for rogue states, and that a 'nonsense' has been made of the public consultation.

 


Global Network Yorkshire CND Campaign for the Accountability of American Bases