A TELEVISION documentary in which Shimon Peres, Israel's foreign minister,
discloses for the first time details about Israel's acquisition of nuclear
weapons is to be broadcast in the Arab world. It is intended, at a time of
rising tensions, as a warning.
Mordechai Vanunu: jailed for the Israeli nuclear programme
In the documentary, Mr Peres goes further than any other Israeli official in
confirming that the Jewish state has a nuclear capability. He and former French
government officials give details about co-operation between Israel and France
in launching Israel's nuclear programme.
The film, made by a leading Israeli documentary team, is a sign that
the government may be finally relaxing its rule of absolute silence
on its nuclear programme. Mordechai Vanunu, a technician at the
Dimona nuclear facility, is serving an 18-year jail sentence for
revealing in 1986 that Israel had a nuclear programme and more than
100 warheads.
The documentary, The Bomb in the Basement: Israel's Nuclear Option,
was shown in Israel last month and is being sold to leading Arabic
television stations including Al-Jazeera, the Qatar-based satellite
channel.
The makers of the film believe that the government's co-operation in
speaking about the origins of its nuclear capability was prompted by
concerns over international terrorism and the expectation that Iran
will have a nuclear capability within a few years.
The documentary's Israeli director, Michael Karpin, who previously
made a controversial film about the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin,
said he was not sure until a few weeks ago whether military censors
would allow the programme to be broadcast.
"It could be that after September 11 they [the government] decided
that perhaps the time had come to reveal a little bit more about the
Israeli nuclear project," Mr Karpin said. "I think the decision to
let it go ahead has to do with the idea of wanting to tell the Arab
world: 'Listen we have it'."
The film reveals how France helped Israel on its nuclear programme in
exchange for support in the Suez War. In the mid-1950s, relations
between the two countries were warming because of their shared
anxiety over burgeoning nationalist movements in North Africa.
Israel feared that the rise of Gamal Abdel Nasser in Egypt would embolden an already formidable foe, while France faced an Arab
insurrection in Algeria, one of its last colonies. Their interests
converged in 1956 when Israel agreed to team up with France and
Britain in a war to punish Nasser for nationalising the Suez Canal.
At the end of September 1956, in Sevres near Paris, Mr Peres, then a
30-year-old Defence Ministry official, accompanied David Ben-Gurion,
Israel's first prime minister, to a meeting with French and British
delegations about the Suez crisis. The Israelis waited for the
British delegation to leave before approaching the French on the
matter of its nuclear project.
Mr Peres said: "In Sevres, when it was all over, I told Ben-Gurion,
'There's one piece of unfinished business: the nuclear issue. Before
you agree, let me finish that.' Of the four countries which at that
time had a nuclear capacity - the United States, the Soviet Union,
Great Britain and France - only France was willing to help us."
Mr Peres is asked in the documentary whether Israel requested a
nuclear reactor. He replies: "I asked for more than that. I asked for
other things, too; the uranium and those things. I went up to Ben-Gurion and said, 'It's settled.' That's how it was."
Mr Ben-Gurion approved Israel's participation in the Suez campaign.
On October 29, 1956, 400 Israeli paratroopers were dropped in western
Sinai in the first phase of the attack on Egypt.
The agreement with France was unprecedented. Until then, no country
had supplied another with the means for developing a nuclear
capability. Mr Karpin believes that Mr Peres may have been motivated
to speak on the subject because he hopes that it will help to secure
his place in history.
In Paris, Jean-Francois Daguzan, the deputy director of the
Foundation for Strategic Research, said that France's deal with
Israel had been kept a secret for almost 30 years. "It was well known
in military and political circles but it didn't become public
knowledge until the mid-1980s after a book was published about that
era and the agreement was mentioned.
"There was no suggestion that France had given Israel its nuclear
capacity but it had certainly helped the country acquire it."
Israel still officially neither confirms nor denies making nuclear
weapons at the plant near Dimona. The country's journalists use coded
language, never stating unequivocally that Israel has the bomb. The
policy of ambiguity was crafted to deter Arabs from attacking Israel
while avoiding the political fallout of becoming an acknowledged
nuclear power.
The documentary marks the first time that the Israeli broadcasting
media has dealt with the issue candidly. Some commentators are
surprised that the censors allowed Mr Karpin such leeway as in the
past six months Israel has detained an academic over a book he wrote
on the country's nuclear capacity and jailed Yitzhak Yaakov, a
retired general, for talking to a journalists on the subject.
|