|

Presidents Jiang Zemin of China and Vladimir
V. Putin of Russia at their treaty signing in the Kremlin.
|
 |
MOSCOW, July 16 — Russia and
China signed a treaty of "friendship and cooperation"
today, binding the two giants closer in the next 20 years and also
committing them to oppose jointly much of the framework for
international security that the United States is seeking to erect
after the cold war.
Composed of 25 articles, the treaty
joins Russia and China formally in opposing the United States'
missile plans and places Russia more firmly behind China's claim of
sovereignty over the island of Taiwan. It also strengthens military
cooperation between Beijing and Moscow while rejecting the
intervention that NATO undertook in 1999 in the Balkans to stop the
killing of civilians.
The accord, sought by China, was
concluded in a Kremlin ceremony with effusive gestures of
camaraderie. The treaty bears the markings of a strategic pact that
sets forth the deep concerns shared by Moscow and Beijing about a
new world order dominated by the United States and its European
allies. The agreement will quite likely be the center of discussion
this week when President Bush and the leaders of the large
industrial countries sit down with President Vladimir V. Putin of
Russia at a summit meeting in Genoa, Italy.
One Russian commentator here
described the treaty as "an act of friendship against
America."
In Washington, the Bush
administration played down the importance of the pact, saying it
fell far short of cementing an alliance between the two countries.
Officials said the accord had been in the works for a long time and
was no surprise. [Article and excerpts, Page A8.]
Mr. Putin and President Jiang Zemin
of China went to some length to explain that the accord, the first
such agreement signed since the era of Stalin and Mao, was between
neighbors that are seeking a new stability for Asian growth and
development while carrying no content related to military alliance.
In a joint statement, the two nations
said that they were hoping for a "just and rational new
international order" and that the merger of their interests
enshrined today were "not directed against third
countries."
But in a striking similarity to the
treaty politics of the cold war, in which Soviet leaders sought
Presidents Richard M. Nixon and Gerald R. Ford to sign thinly
disguised accords against China under Mao, the treaty signed today
requires Moscow and Beijing to coordinate their response closely in
the event that either is subjected to pressure or aggression from
another power.
"If a threat of aggression
arises," the treaty states, the two sides "will
immediately make contact with each other and hold consultations in
order to eliminate the emerging threat."
In addition, it elaborates on Mr.
Putin and Mr. Jiang's opposition to the principle of humanitarian
intervention, established in the NATO Balkan campaign to stop
Serbian violence against civilians in Kosovo.
The pact says Russia and China
"uphold the strict observance of generally recognized
principles and norms of international law against any actions aimed
at exerting pressure or interfering, under any pretext, with the
internal affairs of the sovereign states."
For China, Russia's affirmation of
Chinese sovereignty over Taiwan, now cemented in the more muscular
confines of this treaty, follows the Bush administration's decision
this year to sell an array of weaponry to the island, which has been
estranged from the mainland for half a century.
"The government of the People's
Republic of China is the sole legitimate government representing the
whole of China" and "Taiwan is an integral part of
China," the document states. The language is certain to cause
alarm on Taiwan, where pro-independence leaders look to the United
States to defend them against pressures from Beijing for
reunification.
Russia is China's largest supplier
for high-technology weaponry, as the United States is Taiwan's
largest supplier under the terms of the Taiwan Relations Act of
1979, which binds Washington to provide adequate resources to the
island so that it can defend itself in case of military pressure.
On missile defense, the two leaders
said, "Russia and China stress the basic importance of the
Antiballistic Missile Treaty, which is a cornerstone of strategic
stability and the basis for reducing offensive weapons." Both
countries "speak out for maintaining the treaty in its current
form," the pact adds.
That last statement will complicate
the Bush administration's strategy. Last week, it indicated that it
would seek an agreement with Russia to allow the United States to
conduct an aggressive program of testing missile defense
interceptors and building missile silos and radar systems in Alaska
without treating those tests as violations of the 1972 ABM accord.
In a news conference today that
followed the signing of documents, officially called the Treaty on
Good Neighborly Friendship and Cooperation Between the Russian
Federation and the People's Republic of China, Mr. Jiang addressed
the strategic dimensions of pact, saying an increase in cooperation
between Beijing and Moscow would improve global stability.
"We believe that more active
cooperation between our countries in discussing missile defenses and
disarmament will enhance our efforts in building a multipolar world
and establish a fair, rational international order," the
Chinese leader said.
Mr. Putin agreed, and he seemed to be
positioning himself to arrive at the summit meeting this week, where
he is to meet Mr. Bush for the second time, as the spokesman for a
larger constituency of countries disaffected with American
leadership.
"We believe predictability in
relations based on good neighborliness and legal ties" between
Russia and China "will influence international affairs in a
considerable and positive way," Mr. Putin said.
In a corollary to his summitry, Mr.
Putin also more forcefully stated Russia's opposition to NATO
expansion, a round of which is to be announced at a summit meeting
in Prague in November 2002.
Speaking in an interview with the
Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera, Mr. Putin said further
expansion to Russia's borders would prolong the divisions of the
cold war. "The problem should be simple," he said.
"In the West, everyone says, `We don't want new divisions in
Europe, we don't want new Berlin Walls.' Good. We completely
agree."
"But when NATO enlarges,
division doesn't disappear, it simply moves toward our
borders," he said, complaining that NATO actions in Europe were
free to pursue the political objectives of the Western alliance,
even when there was no agreement in the United Nations Security
Council for action.
"The divisions will continue
until there is a single security area in Europe," he told the
Italian newspaper. He suggested that just as the Warsaw Pact was
disbanded, that NATO could, too, be disbanded in favor of a broader
security structure, presumably one that included Russia. "But
that is not even taken into consideration," he said.
In addition to the strategic
dimension of the treaty, Russia and China formally agreed to reduce
further military forces in border regions, fight terrorism and drug
trafficking, work to resolve the final disputes along their 2,550
miles of border and prevent "groups" or third countries
from using the territory of one country as a base against the other.
They also agreed not to aim their strategic nuclear weapons at the
other and said they would work to solve any dispute peacefully.
Though China is more ideologically
aligned with Russia today, its trade routes lie elsewhere,
especially to the United States, where trade volume was $115 billion
last year, compared with less than $10 billion with Russia.
An important element of the accord,
therefore, is to increase sales from the Russian oil, gas, nuclear
and armaments industries, which Mr. Putin has been assiduously
promoting in his diplomatic travels since taking office. The Tupolov
airplane factory is hoping to take away a piece of the China market
for passenger jets from Boeing
this year with a 10-plane sale of TU-204 jets. And Gazprom,
the Russian state energy giant, last week won a contract to lay a
2,400-mile gas pipeline to carry 20 billion cubic meters of gas a
year from fields from the Xinjiang region in western China to
Shanghai.
Mr. Jiang will make a visit to World
War II memorials in Volgograd, site of the decisive Battle of
Stalingrad, and then travel to Belarus, Moldova and Malta before
returning home.